Latest Posts

Former Chiefs and Pirates Joins Mamelodi Sundowns Defiant Rulani Mokwena Ready For Galaxy Battle Kaizer Chiefs Handed A Major Transfer Boost Lebohang Maboe Linked With Sundowns Exit Keletso Makgalwa: Another Twist In Alleged Chiefs Move Monnapule Saleng’s Future at Orlando Pirates Remains Uncertain Dstv Premiership Club Shows Interest In Itumeleng Khune? Khama Billiat At Risk Of Losing His House Tim Sukazi Backs Ramovic For Chiefs Hot Seat Kaizer Chiefs Told To Copy Sundowns To Return To Glory Days

In the high-stakes MTN8 semifinal 1st leg clash between Kaizer Chiefs and Mamelodi Sundowns at FNB Stadium, former PSL referee Victor Hlongwane has stirred up controversy.

Kaizer Chiefs Mamelodi Sundowns
Pule Mmodi battling Khuliso Mudau during Kaizer Chiefs and Mamelodi Sundowns 2023 MTN8 semifinal 1st leg clash at FNB Stadium.

He suggested that two key players, Pule Mmodi and Khuliso Mudau, should have been shown red cards for their actions during the match.

IN OTHER NEWS: Kaizer Chiefs Delivers A Masterpiece In Gauteng Development League


In the 41st minute of the game, Mmodi, the Kaizer Chiefs star, found himself in the spotlight for a reckless challenge.

Mmodi lunged at Sundowns’ defender Aubrey Modiba, catching Modiba’s left ankle after he had quickly moved the ball away from the oncoming Mmodi.

The referee’s decision, in this case, was to issue a yellow card to Mmodi, which Hlongwane believed was insufficient given the severity of the tackle.

Speaking on Soccerzone on SABC 1, Victor Hlongwane didn’t stop there.


He also questioned the referee’s judgment in another incident involving Mudau, the Mamelodi Sundowns defender.

In the 84th minute of the match, Mudau was shown a yellow card for putting his hand on Ashley Du Preez as he attempted to shield the ball.

However, the real controversy arose later in the game when Mudau found himself in a similar situation against Reeve Frosler.

To the surprise of many, the referee did not produce a second yellow card for Mudau, which would have resulted in a red card and his ejection from the game.

IN OTHER NEWS: RIP: Former Kaizer Chiefs Star Passes On

Hlongwane strongly argued that Mudau’s actions in the second incident should have warranted a second yellow card, leading to his expulsion from the match.

This decision, he believed, would have been more consistent with the severity of the offense and the overall fairness of the game.

The controversial referee decisions involving Mmodi and Mudau have sparked heated debates among fans, analysts, and football enthusiasts alike.

While referees often face the challenging task of making quick decisions in the heat of the moment, the debate surrounding these incidents underscores the importance of consistency and clarity in officiating decisions in top-level football matches.

IN OTHER NEWS: Gaston Sirino Get His SA ID Book

As the MTN8 semifinal continues and both teams strive for victory, these contentious incidents will undoubtedly remain a talking point, reminding us that football’s beauty often lies in its ability to ignite passionate discussions both on and off the field.

About Author

Views: 8

Leave a Reply

HTML Snippets Powered By :

Discover more from

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading